please visit our new site at
​nittissupperclub.com

NITTI'S SUPPER CLUB PRESENTS

WHO KILLED EDDIE O'HARE?

A True Crime History Mystery Musical

$80 per guest
includes show & 3-course meal*

6:00PM doors open
6:30PM dinner service begins
7:15PM showtime
9:15PM Curtain

UPCOMING PERFORMANCES

chicago SHOWS

HARRY CARAY'S ITALIAN STEAKHOUSE
33 W. Kinzie Street, Chicago IL

LOMBARD SHOWS

HARRY CARAY'S ITALIAN STEAKHOUSE
70 Yorktown Center, Lombard IL
Saturday, May 3
Saturday, June 7
Saturday, July 12
Sunday, July 13
​Saturday, August 9
Friday, June 13th
Doors @ 7pm

​Saturday, June 14th
Doors @ 6pm
  • ABOUT THE SHOW
  • VIEW THE MENU
  • FAQS

ABOUT THE SHOW

Step inside landmark building of Harry Caray's Italian Steakhouse, once owned by infamous Chicago mobster Frank Nitti, and travel back in time for dinner and a show based on the real-life murder of Eddie O'Hare.​

This irreverent comedy features an ensemble cast of characters, many of whom walked the very halls of 33 W. Kinzie back when Nitti called it home. The immersive experience invites you to step into the role of partygoer at Frank Nitti's birthday, and delve into the unsolved murder of Edward J. "Easy Eddie" O'Hare -- Al Capone's lawyer and father of war hero Butch O'Hare for whom the airport is named. The crime was never solved, but suspects included Frank Nitti, his wife Annette, Al Capone and several others. Can you crack the case?

The interactive show is filled with historical anecdotes, laughs, audience interaction and toe-tapping musical productions.

DINNER MENU

Starters

MIXED BABY GREENS (GF)
Carrots, Radishes, Grape Tomatoes, Cucumber, Balsamic Vinaigrette

entrées
select one

HARRY’S CHICKEN VESUVIO (GF)
Boneless Breast, Quartered Potatoes, Sweet Peas, Garlic, White Wine

CAVATAPPI WITH ITALIAN SAUSAGE
Red Pepper Flakes, Basil, Cream, Marinara

EGGPLANT PARMIGIANA

Speakeasy Special

+ $15
​Upgrade your entrée to a 6oz filet
Served with Spinach and Mashed Potatoes

Dessert
select one

FLOURLESS CHOCOLATE CAKE (GF)

ELI'S CHICAGO STYLE CHEESECAKE

BAR MENU

A full bar with ​beer, wine and liquor will be available for purchase throughout the show, including our specialty speakeasy cocktails!

​NITTI GRITTY OLD FASHIONED
Maker's Mark Bourbon, Angostura Bitters,
Demerara Syrup, Amarena Cherry

BATHTUB GIN GIMLET
Sipsmith Gin, Fresh Lime Juice, Simple Syrup

TEQUILA DAISY
Tres Generaciones Tequila, Grand Marnier,
​Lemon Sours, Simple Syrup

KNOW BEFORE YOU GO

LOCATION DETAILS

location details

CHICAGO
Harry Caray's Italian Steakhouse
33 W. Kinzie Street
Chicago, IL 60654
​(312) 828-9600
LOMBARD
Harry Caray's Italian Steakhouse
70 Yorktown Center
Lombard, IL 60148
(630) 953-3400
Please be sure to note which location you have purchased tickets for. 
performance itinerary

performance itinerary

5:45 PM
Guided tour of Nitti's Vault & Tunnel
(OPTIONAL ADD-ON)  | $15/guest  •  Limited Availability (12 slots per show)

Guests are invited to arrive early for an guided tour of the secret tunnel before the show! Long before 33 W. Kinzie was one of Chicago’s most famous steakhouses, it was home to the notorious enforcer of the Al Capone gang, Frank Nitti.  In 1998, an electrician drilled a hole in the wall of the basement that revealed a hidden room spanning the length of the upstairs bar. The room was used as a hideout during the Prohibition era as well as a passageway to Chicago’s underground tunnel system, allowing Nitti and his associates to come and go without being seen on the streets of Chicago.

The tour begins promptly at 5:45, so we recommend arriving by 5:30.

Please note, the tour includes unfinished areas of the building that include possible tripping hazards.
A signed Liability & Release Form is required for all participants.

6:00 PM
​Doors Open

Please check in at the host stand by 6:15pm. No confirmation email or printed tickets required, your reservation will be listed on our guest list under the name used at checkout.

6:30 PM
showtime!

Dinner service starts at 6:30pm, and the show will begin once everyone has been served their entrée.
LATE ARRIVALS, cancelationS, & refund poliCY

late arrivals

Guests must be seated by 6:30pm in order to select their choice of dinner options. Late arrivals will receive the Cavatappi with Italian Sausage and Flourless Chocolate Cake. Alternatively, if you are aware you may be arriving late, you can call ahead to place your order before 6:30pm. Let the host your are attending Nitti’s and would like to place your dinner order ahead of time, as you may arrive late.

CHICAGO SHOWS: (312) 828-0966  |  LOMBARD SHOWS: (630) 953-3400

CANCELATION & REFUND POLICY

Tickets are fully refundable up to 14 days before the show. Cancellations within 14 days will receive a 50% refund. Cancellations within 48 hours are non-refundable.

If you are no longer able to attend, please email [email protected] as soon as possible if you would like to cancel or reschedule for a future performance.
table arrangements
Please be advised, there is a limited number of deuces available at a first come, first serve basis. Once those tables are filled, smaller groups may be seated together.

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

do i need to show my ticket at check-in?
No tickets or confirmation emails will need to be provided for entry, there will be a list at check-in where guests will be asked which name their reservation is under.

If you purchased tickets as a gift for someone else and are not attending yourself, please feel free to email [email protected] to confirm what name the reservation is under.
what is the dress code?
​Nitti's Supper Club does not require a specific dress code. You're welcome to express yourself thematically if you're feeling inspired — embracing your inner mobster with a sharp suit or getting all dolled up in your finest flapper attire can add a fun flair to your evening. However, if you prefer to keep it casual and wear what you'd normally wear to dine at Harry Caray's, that's perfectly fine too. We want you to feel comfortable and enjoy the experience however you choose to dress.
WHAT PARKING & TRANSPORTATION OPTIONS ARE AVAILABLE?

CHICAGO LOCATION

VALET
Valet parking is available for $15.

STREET PARKING & PARKING GARAGES
There is limited paid street parking available, but there are several parking garages within the nearby vicinity.

PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION
The restaurant is walking distance (10-15 minute walk) from the following L Stations:
  • State/Lake Brown Line / Green Line / Orange Line / Pink Line / Purple Line
  • State St. Red Line
  • Clark/Lake Blue Line / Brown Line / Green Line / Orange Line / Pink Line / Purple Line
  • Merchandise Mart Brown Line / Purple Line
  • Grand Red Line

BUS PARKING
Bus parking is available for large groups and must be coordinated in advance. For more information email [email protected].

lombard LOCATION​

FREE PARKING
Complimentary self-parking is available in the Yorktown Plaza Shopping Center
what is included in the cost of my ticket?
Ticket price includes the show, a three-course meal, and soft drinks.

In addition to the standard dinner options, we offer a full bar with ​beer, wine and liquor available for purchase throughout the show, and an optional $15 steak entrée upgrade. This "Speakeasy Special" includes a 6oz steak served with spinach and mashed potatoes. Anyone interested in upgrading their meal can do so when placing their order. The upgrade, along with any cocktails or alcoholic beverages, will be added to your individual bill at the end of the evening.

Tax and gratuity are not included.

a note about gratuity

A gentle reminder that gratuity is not included in the ticket cost. Our talented cast of performers work double-duty as your servers for the evening. Please remember to tip accordingly when your bar bill arrives at the end of the night.
CAN I ADD ADDITIONAL PEOPLE TO MY RESERVATION?
​If you wish to add guests to your party, you must purchase additional tickets in advance. Please make a note during check out to let us know that you would like to be seated as a group and include the name the other reservation is under.

If no tickets are available online that means the performance is sold out and no additional guests can be added to your party.

give the gift of nitti's supper club!

Not sure which performance date will work best for your recipient? No problem! Purchase a Nitti's Supper Club Gift Certificate, and let them pick the perfect date to enjoy the show.

​It’s a one-of-a-kind gift that's perfect for foodies, Chicago history buffs, mob aficionados, fans of dinner theater, or anyone looking for a fun night out.

optional add on
guided tour of
nitti's vAULT & tunnel
•   $15/guest   •
Limited Availability

Before the show, we offer an optional guided tour of the tunnel below the building that Frank Nitti and his associates used to move undetected below the streets of Chicago.

​The tour begins promptly at 5:45 PM, so we recommend arriving by 5:30 PM.

The tour is limited to 12 guests and can be reserved for $15/ person. Only available for Chicago location performances.​
​*Ticket prices do not include tax, gratuity, or alcoholic beverages. ​Alcoholic beverages can be purchased during the show.
​Nitti's Supper Club is family-friendly, but we kindly ask that any children attending be able to remain seated and well-behaved during the performance.
You're also invited to join us in Harry's Bar before or after the show. While you're there, make sure to check out NITTI'S VAULT located beneath the Bar. View the secret room, the possessions discovered within it, along with photographs, newspaper articles and legal documents from Nitti’s life. One of the most exciting finds was a large safe with three layers of security buried in the basement walls. Also found was  Nitti’s personal address book, listing the home addresses and phone numbers of powerful government officials and mobsters. Nitti's Vault has been named #1 on Thrillist's list of Hidden Urban Treasures You Need to Find.

allskate86

/

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
One of the best times ever! We had a preteen, a teenager, 2 adults and 3 seniors and we all had a blast! We were so impressed by everyone there. Great singing and wonderful audience participation in an intimate setting. Food was excellent. I had 6 of the "actors" come up to me to compliment me after I was selected to go onstage. There was such attention to detail and everyone went out of their way to make us all feel welcome. I'd highly encourage anyone to go. You will not be sorry you did!

allskate86

/

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Elizabeth K.

/

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All the food is delish! The show is great! It's interactive, and gives some amazing Chicago history in the process. There was some great heckling back and forth between the actors and audience. Their improvisation is top notch and the musicians are superb! I highly recommend for a fun evening.

jd

/

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Susan A

/

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Superb! The entire crew were so engaging with the crowd. Excellent music and stage presentation! My entire
family loved it! It was a night to remember, filled with laughs and great company! Job well done!

Jennifer

/

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Jim

/

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
I loved the actors (gangsters & flappers) and the guy at the door holding a Tommy Gun checking passwords. The food was delicious and it was a fun show. VERY audience interactive. The actors and actresses also were the waiters and waitresses all dressed up. So cute!

Jim

/

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

ianegostudios

/

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
The show was fabulous! Love the audience/dinner guest participation. Food was delicious especially the cheesecake. Definitely worth the money and will be back with friends and possibly costumes. =)

ianegostudios

/

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4

THE PLACE: 33 WEST KINZIE

Long before 33 W. Kinzie housed one of Chicago’s most famous steakhouses, it was home to the notorious enforcer of the Al Capone gang, Frank Nitti. He lived in an apartment on the fourth floor with his wife Annette. They operated a legitimate Italian food business, Caravetta Foods, out of the building. But it was also a convenient hideout for Nitti as the courthouse building was clearly visible from the apartment. The building connected to Chicago's underground tunnel system allowing Nitti and his associates to come and go without being seen on the streets.

Nitti's Supper Club tells a story of real characters from Nitti's life of crime who would have walked through the doors of 33 West Kinzie. Join them on a trip back in time to the raucous world of gangland Chicago. 

THE MENU

Choose from a selection of favorites from Harry's menu!
​
 STARTERS
MIXED BABY GREENS (GF)
Carrots, Radishes, Grape Tomatoes, Cucumber, Balsamic Vinaigrette

ENTREES
HARRY’S CHICKEN VESUVIO (GF)
Boneless Breast, Quartered Potatoes, Sweet Peas, Garlic, White Wine
or
CAVATAPPI WITH ITALIAN SAUSAGE
Red Pepper Flakes, Basil, Cream, Marinara
or
EGGPLANT PARMIGIANA

DESSERT
FLOURLESS CHOCOLATE CAKE
or
ELI’S CHICAGO STYLE CHEESECAKE



​Beer, wine and liquor will be available for purchase throughout the show, including our specialty speakeasy cocktails!

​NITTI GRITTY OLD FASHIONED
Maker's Mark Bourbon, Angostura Bitters,
Demerara Syrup, Cherry Garnish

THE SOUTHSIDE
Sipsmith Gin, Fresh Lime Juice,
​Angostura Bitters, Simple Syrup

THE CARAVETTA
Cruzan Rum, Fresh Lime Juice, Raspberry Purée

Check out another chicago true crime experience!

Chicago Crime Tours and Experiences is a true crime history bus tour. Explore historic crime scenes on and off the bus on this multi-sensory experience for a memorable and fun way to see Chicago. 

THE CAST & CREDITS

script by MARGARET rAETHER

ANASTASIA aRNOLD Ursula "Sue" Granata

Anastasia is thrilled to bring this true crime history mystery to life! A few of her theatre credits include: Paramount Theatre, Porchlight Theatre, Metropolis Theatre, Chicago Kid’s Company, Music Theatre Works, and Tommy Gun’s Garage. Huge thanks to the team at Harry Caray’s for trusting us with this story and for everyone that helped make it a reality! Shoutout to her husband (Tyler) and dog (Vinny) for being the best support system she could ask for. Salud!

Brett Baleskie Al Capone

Brett is a Chicago native who has been freelancing in the theater industry for over a decade as a performer, scenic designer/painter, choreographer and director. Teaching has become an integral part of Brett’s mission as an artist. He has worked with numerous schools and theater companies in the Chicagoland area. Thank you to all of those who have supported and believed in him. brettbaleskie.com

Norm Boucher Frank Nitti

Norm is thrilled to be working with this amazing creative team. He has worked at Court Theatre, Chicago Shakespeare, Theatre at the Center, Drury Lane Oakbrook, Marriott Lincolnshire, Royal George, and The Goodman. His favorite roles have been Max Bialystock in The Producers, Nathan Detroit in Guys and Dolls, and Oscar Madison in The Odd Couple. His TV credits include Chicago PD, Chicago Fire, Early Edition, and numerous commercials. He teaches Voiceover at Acting Studio Chicago, and sings for The Blooze Brothers Band. He is grateful for his wife and best friend Nancy Jane Nelson.

Dina Dicostanzo director

Dina is a Director, Choreographer, and Performer who works regularly in and around Chicagoland. Directing and choreography credits include Porchlight Theatre, Metropolis Theatre, Roosevelt University, Highland Park Players, Music on Stage, Fremont Street, The Performer’s School, and more. Dina also choreographed the 2019 hit, Miracle the Musical, a show Harry Caray would have loved, about the Cubs 2016 World Series win that saw a successful run at the Royal George. Her stage accomplishments include work at Paramount Theatre, Marriott Theatre Lincolnshire, Drury Lanes Oakbrook and Water Tower, Victory Gardens, The Mercury, The Lakeshore, Theatre at the Center, Northlight Theatre, Center Stage Baltimore and Capital Rep in Albany, NY. 

Jeff Diebold detective Thomas Kelly

Jeff was last seen playing Hertz Klineman in Mercury Theater’s Rock of Ages. He was also in Mercury’s Jeff Award-Winning productions of Spamalot as King Arthur and The Addams Family as Lurch. Other recent Chicago credits: The King’s Speech, Nell Gwynn (Chicago Shakespeare Theater), My Fair Lady (Lyric Opera of Chicago) and Mamma Mia! at the Paramount Theater in Aurora. He also has a recurring role as Scott in NBC’s Chicago Fire. He received his MFA in Acting from Roosevelt University’s Chicago College of Performing Arts and is glad you came out tonight and hopes you have a great time.

Ariane Dolan Margie Costello

Ariane has been performing in and around the Chicago area for most of her life. She has been seen on the stage at The Goodman, Chicago Shakespeare Theatre, The Lyric Opera of Chicago, Marriott Theater, Drury Lane Theater and many others. She teaches various forms of dance at Columbia College, Roosevelt University, and The Chicago Movement Collective. She was Julia Stiles’ Ballet Double in the Paramount film Save the Last Dance.

Kelly Lohrenz Rosie O'Houlihan / Ursula "Sue" Granata

Kelly is thrilled to be making her Nitti's Supper Club debut! A graduate of Western Illinois University, she has performed at various theaters across the Midwest. Most recent Chicago credits include The Producers and White Christmas (Music Theater Works), and Don't Dress for Dinner (Theater D). Other favorite roles include Gypsy (Louise), Chicago (Roxie), The Rocky Horror Show (Magenta), and 25th...Spelling Bee (Olive). When not onstage, you can find her teaching dance classes or in the kitchen creating custom decorated sugar cookies with her cottage food operation, Blissful Betty, blissfulbetty.com. Much love to her family and the Nitti's Supper Club crew!

Mary Jane Nelson Annette Caravetta

Nancy Jane is excited to join the cast of Nitti’s Supper Club! Based in Chicago, some of her favorite roles include Mavis in The Church Basement Ladies at The Fireside Theatre and Maples Rep, Vickie in The Full Monty at Mason Street Warehouse, Pennywise in Urinetown at The Mercury Theatre, Olivia in Twelfth Night at Oakpark Festival Theatre, Mama Bull in The Story of Ferdinand at Lifeline Theatre, Patsy in Always Patsy Cline at Door Off Broadway Theatre, Fanny and Director at Tommy Gun’s Garage, and member of Route 66 Female A Cappella Quartet. She has done numerous commercials, voice-overs, and industrials, and was featured on Chicago Fire. She thanks the Gun’s Gals for including her in the fun and her best friend and husband Norm Boucher.

Allyssa O'Donnell Rosie O'Houlihan

Allyssa is thrilled to return to Nitti's Supper Club! She is a Chicago based director, choreographer, actor and teaching artist. She currently is the Creative Director of BAMtheatre, a nationally recognized theatre training program, introducing theatre to hundreds of new students each year. She has directed and choreographed for both professionals and students at BAMtheatre, Bravo Performing Arts, CPA Theatricals, Metropolis Performing Arts Center, Elmhurst Children's Theatre and Stacey De & Co. She has performed at Theatre at the Center, Music Theatre Works, Chicago Kids Company, Metropolis, Medieval Times Chicago, and Tommy Guns Garage. She holds her BFA in Musical Theatre from Ball State University. 

Casiena Raether Rosie O'Houlihan

Casiena is thrilled to be working with such a fabulous cast of performers. Favorite credits include A Chorus Line (Cassie), Billy Elliott (Mrs. Wilkinson), Mamma Mia (Tanya), White Christmas (Judy), and many other shows, including a year-long stint singing and dancing her way through the South Pacific aboard a cruise ship. When she's not teaching or choreographing, she enjoys spending time outdoors with her husband and wiener dogs. Enjoy the show!

Rob Rahn Frank Nitti

Rob is pleased to be working with this great group of professionals. He has worked professionally in over 100 musical theatre productions in Chicago and the midwest at such theaters as The Marriott Lincolnshire, Chicago Shakespeare, The Goodman Theatre, Drury Lane Oakbrook, Candlelight Theatre, Theatre at the Center, and many others. Rob and wife, Liz Fauntleroy, singer and voice teacher, are proud parents of 4 grown up men- Adam, Kevin, Justin and Tommy.

Tyler Sonkin Al Capone

Tyler is thrilled to be part of the Nitti’s Supper Club. Tyler is a Chicago based actor with a BA in Theatre from Millikin University. Notable credits include: Brick Escape to Margaritaville, Bill Austin Mamma Mia, Ghost of Christmas Present/Fezziwig A Christmas Carol (musical), Joe 9 to 5, Curly McLain Oklahoma, Man in Chair The Drowsy Chaperone, Billy Crocker Anything Goes, Smudge Plaid Tidings, Bill Calhoun Kiss Me, Kate, Prince Eric The Little Mermaid, Galahad/Black Knight/Herbert’s Father Spamalot and Amos Calloway Big Fish.  Tyler would like to thank his family and friends for all of their love and support.

Ryan Stajmiger Detective Thomas Kelly

Ryan has worked with Chicago area theaters including Mercury Theater, Marriott, Paramount, Chicago Shakespeare, Drury Lane, Porchlight, and Skylight Music Theater. Outside of theater Ryan can be found carving pumpkins (check out @staj_o_lanterns on Instagram and Tik Tok) and performing with Franki Valli and The Four Seasons Tribute, The Four C Notes.

Lucy Zukaitis Margie Costello

Lucy is excited and grateful for the opportunity to create this show. She’s worked with Chicago area theaters including the Lyric Opera, the Paramount, Drury Lane Oakbrook, Mercury Theatre, Illinois Theatre Center, and the John G. Shedd Aquarium. She's also performed at Peterborough Players, Peninsula Players, the Omaha Theatre Company, and the Nebraska Shakespeare Festival. Favorite roles: Amanda Prynne in Private Lives and Lisette/Prudence in the regional premiere of Dumas' Camille (Peterborough Players). TV: The Big Leap (FOX), Drinks, Crime & Prohibition (Smithsonian Network). Film: A Compassionate Spy, Nutcrackers. Lucy is also an audiobook narrator, crossword enthusiast, and a devotee of racquet sports. @lucyintheskywithcubiczirconias 

Production coordinators:
Anastasia Arnold & Lucy Zukaitis

Additional Writing Credits:
nORM bOUCHER, jEFF dIEBOLD, rYAN sTAJMIGER

Holy Cow! Thanks for stopping by!

The Company |  Media Kit |  Employment |  ​Contact